Would you rather
Would you rather sail with a crew of cats or a crew of penguins?
A crew of cats is independent and stubborn but good at catching mice on board; a crew of penguins swims well and works as a team, but cannot climb the rigging.
How 110 players answered
- Cats57%63
- Penguins43%47
Most people expected “Cats” to win, and it did: 54% saw it coming.
From 110 answers on the day it was asked, most recently Sunday, November 8, 2026. Today’s answers are added at 12:15 AM New York time.
More would you rather questions
- Would you rather explore a sunken pirate ship or a giant coral reef?
- Would you rather be a mermaid for a day or a centaur for a day?
- Would you rather be a cloud for a day or a wave for a day?
- Would you rather sail around the world or fly around it in a hot-air balloon?
- Would you rather climb the tallest mountain or cross the biggest desert?
- Would you rather travel by giant eagle or by magic train?
All would you rather questions · This or That Questions · About Majority Rules
Answers come from players of Majority Rules, a free daily game on Gamefinity: totals only, never who answered. A split is shown from 50 answers on past days; the 1253 questions come round every few weeks.