Would you rather
Would you rather have a third arm or a tail?
A third arm helps with carrying and cooking; a tail is good for balance and very bad at hiding how you feel.
How 98 players answered
- Third arm60%59
- A tail40%39
Most people expected “Third arm” to win, and it did: 65% saw it coming.
From 98 answers on the day it was asked, most recently Saturday, November 7, 2026. Today’s answers are added at 12:15 AM New York time.
More would you rather questions
- Would you rather take a road trip or a cruise?
- Would you rather be the best player on a losing team or the worst on a winning team?
- Would you rather always have wet socks or a pebble in your shoe?
- Would you rather give up cheese or give up chocolate?
- Would you rather talk to plants or talk to machines?
- Would you rather have a pet penguin or a pet otter?
All would you rather questions · This or That Questions · About Majority Rules
Answers come from players of Majority Rules, a free daily game on Gamefinity: totals only, never who answered. A split is shown from 50 answers on past days; the 1253 questions come round every few weeks.