This or that · Food fight

Best birthday cake?

Chocolate and vanilla are the classics, carrot cake comes with cream-cheese icing, and an ice cream cake settles what to serve with it.

How 98 players answered

  1. Chocolate47%46
  2. Vanilla16%16
  3. Carrot7%7
  4. Ice cream cake30%29

Most people expected “Chocolate” to win, and it did: 49% saw it coming.

From 98 answers on the day it was asked, most recently Saturday, November 7, 2026. Today’s answers are added at 12:15 AM New York time.

All this or that questions · Would You Rather Questions · About Majority Rules

Answers come from players of Majority Rules, a free daily game on Gamefinity: totals only, never who answered. A split is shown from 50 answers on past days; the 1253 questions come round every few weeks.